SPORTENG specialises in the Planning, Design and Construction inspection of Fields of Play for all sports. Blending engineering with the specialist knowledge gained from working closely with sport…read more
New UNSW study shows effectiveness of strength training for fat loss
A new UNSW study published this week in Sports Medicine shows something that many in the fitness industry would already be aware of - the effectiveness of strength/weight training for fat loss and not just muscle gain and maintenance.
The study - a systematic review and meta-analysis which reviewed and analysed existing evidence - shows around 1.4% of our entire body fat can be lost through strength training alone, which is similar to how much we might lose through cardio or aerobics.
Dr Mandy Hagstrom, exercise physiologist, senior lecturer at UNSW Medicine & Health and senior author of the study, commented “a lot of people think that if you want to lose weight, you need to go out and run.
“But our findings show that even when strength training is done on its own, it still causes a favourable loss of body fat without having to consciously diet or go running.”
The researchers advise that “up until now, the link between strength training and fat loss has been unclear. Studies have investigated this link in the past, but their sample sizes tend to be small - a side effect of not many people wanting to volunteer to exercise for months on end. Smaller sample sizes can make it difficult to find statistically significant results, especially as many bodies can respond differently to exercise programs.
“It can be really difficult to discern whether there’s an effect or not based on one study alone. But when we add all of these studies together, we effectively create one large study, and can get a much clearer idea of what's going on.”
Dr Hagstrom and her team pulled together the findings from 58 research papers that used highly accurate forms of body fat measurement (like body scans, which can differentiate fat mass from lean mass) to measure the outcomes from strength training programs. Altogether, the studies included 3000 participants, none of which had any previous weight training experience.
While the strength training programs differed between the studies, the participants worked out for roughly 45-60 minutes each session for an average of 2.7 times per week. The programs lasted for about five months.
The team found that, on average, the participants lost 1.4% of their total body fat after their training programs, which equated to roughly half a kilo in fat mass for most participants.
While the findings are encouraging for fans of pumping iron, Dr Hagstrom says the best approach for people who are aiming to lose fat is still to stick to eating nutritiously and having an exercise routine that includes both aerobic/cardio and strength training.
However, if aerobics and cardio just aren’t your thing, the good news is you don’t need to force it with Dr Hagstrom noting "if you want to exercise to change your body composition, you’ve got options.
“Do what exercise you want to do and what you’re most likely to stick to.”
Busting the fat loss myth
Part of the reason many people think strength training doesn’t live up to cardio in terms of fat loss comes down to inaccurate ways of measuring fat.
For example, many people focus on the number they see on the scale - that is, their total body weight. But this figure doesn’t differentiate fat mass from everything else that makes up the body, like water, bones and muscles.
Dr Hagstrom added “more often than not, we don't gain any muscle mass when we do aerobic training,.
“We improve our cardiorespiratory fitness, gain other health and functional benefits, and can lose body fat.
“But when we strength train, we gain muscle mass and lose body fat, so the number on the scales won’t look as low as it would after aerobics training, especially as muscle weighs more than fat.”
The research team focused on measuring how much the total body fat percentage - that is, the amount of your body that’s made up of fat mass - changed after strength training programs. This measurement showed fat loss appears to be on par with aerobics and cardio training, despite the different figures on the scales.
Dr Hagstrom went on to say “a lot of fitness recommendations come from studies that use inaccurate measurement tools, like bioelectrical impedance or scales.
“But the most accurate and reliable way of assessing body fat is through DEXA, MRI or CT scans. They can compartmentalise the body and separate fat mass from lean tissue.”
While this study didn’t show whether variables like exercise duration, frequency, intensity, or set volume impacted fat loss percentage, the team hope to next investigate whether how we strength train can change the amount of fat loss.
A better way of measuring progress
As part of their study, the team conducted a sub-analysis comparing how different ways of measuring fat can influence a study’s findings.
Interestingly, it showed that when papers used more accurate measurements like body scans, they tended to show lower overall changes in body fat.
Lead author of the study Michael Wewege, a PhD candidate at UNSW and NeuRA, explained “using accurate fat measurements is important because it gives us a more realistic idea of what body changes to expect.
“Future exercise studies can improve their research by using these more accurate body measurements.”
Reframing the way we measure progress doesn’t just apply to sports researchers, but to everyday people, too.
Dr Hagstrom continues “resistance training does so many fantastic things to the body that other forms of exercise don't, like improving bone mineral density, lean mass and muscle quality. Now, we know it also gives you a benefit we previously thought only came from aerobics.
“If you're strength training and want to change how your body looks, then you don't want to focus on the number on the scale too much, because it won’t show you all your results.
“Instead, think about your whole body composition, like how your clothes fit and how your body will start to feel, and move, differently.”
1st September 2021 - UNSW sociologist advises it’s time to drop the moral panic about fatness
20th November 2020 - UNSW researcher highlights the benefits of HIIT
4th October 2019 - YMCA Victoria launches regular inclusive LGBTIQ+ strength training classes
17th January 2019 - Research shows HIIT training as more than another fitness fad
18th November 2018 - Strength training experts to come together in Perth
22nd July 2018 - Les Mills’ Bryce Hastings suggests upper limit for HIIT training
29th March 2017 - Study shows HIIT the best exercise for anti-ageing
20th February 2017 - Strength training carries weight for obese teens
3rd November 2016 - Fitness Australia calls on Australians to lift the bar on strength training
22nd June 2016 - Boys outperform girls in cardiorespiratory fitness
23rd July 2015 - Precor advises gyms on women-focussed strength training
25th February 2015 - Life Fitness Insignia Series delivers new premium strength training experience
Asking a small favour
We hope that you value the news that we publish so while you're here can we ask for your support?
The news we publish at www.ausleisure.com.au is independent, credible (we hope) and free for you to access, with no pay walls and no annoying pop-up ads.
However, as an independent publisher, can we ask for you to support us by subscribing to the printed Australasian Leisure Management magazine - if you don't already do so.
Published bi-monthly since 1997, the printed Australasian Leisure Management differs from this website in that it publishes longer, in-depth and analytical features covering aquatics, attractions, entertainment, events, fitness, parks, recreation, sport, tourism and venues management.
Subscriptions cost just $90 a year.
Click here to subscribe.
The Complete Guide to Leisure Industry Products & Services.
PROVEN BUSINESS CONCEPTS WITH XBODY XBody’s goal is to see you and your EMS business succeed. That is why we don’t just sell equipment, we provide know-how, expert knowledge,…read more
Otium Planning Group is a contemporary sport and leisure consultancy providing services in planning, facility development, management and funding for the sport, recreation and leisure industries…read more
BH Fitness, part of the long-standing and iconic bike manufacturer BH Group, is a global leader in fitness equipment for both Commercial and Home markets. The company, with the headquarters based in…read more
AUSTRALIAN MADE. FIT FOR PURPOSE. Based on the Gold Coast, AlphaFit is a leading manufacturer and supplier of Australian gym equipment specifically for the commercial, strength and conditioning,…read more
Anti Wave International is the original suppliers of top performance swim, aquatic sports, leisure and pool programming equipment. Founded in 1971, Anti Wave International is proud of its…read more
Humanforce is a global provider of workforce management solutions for companies who need flexibility to manage complex workforces. Companies use Humanforce to manage everything from time and…read more
INTRODUCTION Abel Sports is Australia’s leading manufacturer and suppliers of Goal Posts, sports ground safety netting systems and coaches boxes for Stadiums ,Sports Clubs, Councils and…read more
get listed with our suppliers directory
Get your business noticed in our targeted directory. Viewed by 10,000 industry professionals per week!