AusLeisure

The increasingly controversial redevelopments of Sydney’s Allianz Stadium and ANZ Stadium will deliver negative returns on the NSW Government’s investment, according to business cases from consultants KPMG.

Made public by the NSW Government today following an order by the NSW upper house, the analysis shows that both venues will need to be subsidised over their life cycle, the documents show.

The analysis also reveals that the financial cases are strongly dependent on increasing the number of major events at Allianz Stadium, which runs the risk of reducing ANZ Stadium’s, currently the preferred venue for major events such as sporting finals and internationals along with major outdoor concerts.

The NSW upper house ruling has also seen the release of plans to relocate the Powerhouse Museum – see Massive tower developments to fund relocation of Sydney’s Powerhouse Museum.

The cost-benefit analysis released relates only to the financial cost-benefit. Both reports, argue that the redevelopments will greatly enhance the spectator experience at the venue and provide broader economic and social benefit.

The redevelopments of Sydney’s Allianz Stadium and ANZ Stadium has been subject to a number of changes over recent years with a ‘final’ decision in April 2016 to knockdown and rebuild ANZ Stadium reversed on March following intensive lobbying by members of the Sydney Cricket and Sports Ground Trust, which includes high-profile figures such as broadcaster Alan Jones, businessman Tony Shepherd, former News Ltd Chief Executive John Hartigan and businesswoman Katie Page.

As reported by Guardian Australia, Page’s husband, Gerry Harvey, together with businessman John Singleton, have the lease on the Entertainment Quarter next door to the Moore Park venues, and are also planning a major redevelopment.

The SCG Trust argued that Allianz Stadium, also known as the Sydney Football Stadium, is in urgent need of replacement because it is in breach of fire and safety requirements.

Its replacement as 40,000 to 45,000 venue has a budget of $729 million while the redevelopment of ANZ Stadium will cost $810 million.

The KPMG report on Allianz Stadium shows four options were considered: a base case, involving capital spending $341 million to address the fire and safety concerns, versus two different rebuilds costed at between $750 million and $775 million and an extensive refurbishment which was $714 million. The NSW Government has opted for a knockdown and rebuild at a cost of $729 million.

The analysis acknowledges that the event calendar is the key driver of a venue’s ability to generate revenue and a strong financial performance and suggests more NRL and rugby union fixtures could be staged at the rebuilt Allianz Stadium.

The NSW Government had been resisting making the business cases public but relented last week after the NSW upper house censured the it’s leader in the chamber.

Images: Current concepts for the redevelopment of Sydney’s Allianz Stadium (top) and ANZ Stadium (below).

12th June 2018 - MASSIVE TOWER DEVELOPMENTS TO FUND RELOCATION OF SYDNEY’S POWERHOUSE MUSEUM

21st May 2018 - UTS TAKES ON NAMING RIGHTS AT SOON TO RELOCATE ALLIANZ STADIUM HEALTH CLUB 

2nd May 2018 - ANZ STADIUM OPERATOR VENUESLIVE TO MANAGE NEW WESTERN SYDNEY STADIUM

29th April 2018 - VENUES NSW CHAIR ISSUED WARNING OVER VIABILITY OF SYDNEY STADIUM REDEVELOPMENTS

29th March 2018 - NSW GOVERNMENT ABANDONS ANZ STADIUM REBUILD PLANS, BACKS NEW ALLIANZ STADIUM 

24th November 2017 - NSW GOVERNMENT CONFIRMS MASSIVE REBUILDING PLANS FOR ALLIANZ AND ANZ STADIUMS 

23rd November 2017 - NSW GOVERNMENT TO SPEND MORE THAN $2 BILLION ON ALLIANZ AND ANZ STADIUM REBUILDS

31st August 2017 - VENUES NSW SEEKS OPERATOR FOR NEW WESTERN SYDNEY STADIUM 

27th October 2017 - AUSTRALIAN RUGBY AND SPORTS SCIENCE BASE OPENS IN SYDNEY’S MOORE PARK 

21st July 2017 - NSW GOVERNMENT RELEASES ‘COMMERCIALITY FRAMEWORK’ FOR STADIA 

19th July 2017 - POLLSTAR MID-YEAR RANKINGS SHOW AUSTRALIA’S OUTDOOR VENUES ECLIPSING INDOOR ARENAS

4th May 2017 - ALLIANZ STADIUM GROUND STAFF TO WORK AROUND THE CLOCK TO PREPARE SURFACE FOR A-LEAGUE GRAND FINAL 

3rd May 2017 - MASTER PLAN FOR SYDNEY’S MOORE PARK PROPOSES ENHANCED CONSERVATION AND NEW SPORT FACILITIES 

12th May 2016 - PARTNERSHIP TO DELIVER COMMUNITY, EDUCATION AND SPORTING HUB IN SYDNEY’S MOORE PARK

14th April 2016 - SYDNEY’S STADIUM DEBATE OVER AS NSW GOVERNMENT COMMITS $1.6 BILLION TO REFURBISHMENTS

29th August 2013 - NSW SPORT MINISTER GRAHAM ANNESLEY RESIGNS TO TAKE UP ROLE AT GOLD COAST TITANS

Support our industry news service
We hope that you value the news that we publish so while you're here can we ask for your support?

As an independent publisher, we need reader support for our industry news gathering so ask that - if you don't already do so - you back us by subscribing to the printed Australasian Leisure Management magazine and/or our online news.