Latest News

Back to Latest News back


Conservationist says that Whitsundays shark attacks occurred in swimming ‘no-go zone’

Conservationist says that Whitsundays shark attacks occurred in swimming ‘no-go zone’
September 24, 2018

With four tiger sharks now having been killed in the Whitsundays in the aftermath of two attacks on tourists last week, a Queensland-based conservationist has advised that the area of sea off Whitsunday Island is known by locals as a ‘no-go zone’ for swimming.

Jonathan Clarke, from Sea Shepherd Australia, has spent months inspecting shark drum lines in Queensland. He said the drum lines were often left for days without bait, creating “a false sense of safety” for swimmers.

Four tiger sharks were killed at the weekend by baited hooks dropped into Sawmill Bay by Fisheries Queensland following the attacks on Justine Barwick, aged 46, and Hannah Papps, aged 12.

Advising that fishemen often caught sharks at the site of the attacks, Clarke told AAP “I do know locals who know it very well, and very much the feeling is this is a known area ... as a safe mooring place but it is murky water and it’s not necessarily a safe swimming place.

“(Drum lines are) certainly not going to make it better. So far they’ve caught four sharks, they’re medium-sized tiger sharks. There’s a lot of very large sharks in that area that seem to frequent that area a lot.

“One of the best mitigation methods is good public information. Were locals and visitors adequately warned following the first bite incident?”

The Queensland Government insists drum lines have been effective and their use is supported by Labor and the Liberal National party.

However, Clarke said there was no evidence that was the case. He said his investigation of drum lines showed they were often not even operational.

He added “up in the north, in Cairns, Townsville and Mackay, they’re using mullet on the lines. Within the day, they’re laid out, a lot of the bait is taken. When we monitor it over days and days ... one day we found three of 54 drum lines at Townsville were baited. One day in Mackay, 100% of those drum lines did not have any bait.

“It’s not even a false sense of safety, it’s actually a placebo.”

Clarke said he would not advocate for more regular baiting of the drum lines. Over decades of shark control in Queensland, he said baiting had in some cases created known shark feeding areas.

Both victims were bitten while in shallow water in Cid harbour.

Both victims are in hospital in Brisbane and Hannah is in a critical but stable condition, with Barwick having undergone a marathon 18-hour surgery to save her leg.

Related Articles

22nd September 2018 - Tiger sharks killed in wake of Whitsundays tourist attacks

3rd March 2017 - Record summer visits but no drownings on Queensland beaches

22nd September 2016 - Queensland Coast Safe Report identifies dangerous beaches and older men in drowning hazards

21st September 2018 - Two injured over consecutive days in Whitsunday shark attacks

18th April 2018 - Shark attacks prompt cancellation of Margaret River Pro surfing event

15th May 2014 - Irukandji ‘forecast’ to warn Australian swimmers about presence of deadly stingers

18th March 2018 - NSW shark net trial kills endangered marine life

18th January 2015 - Shark sightings shut Newcastle beaches for a record ninth day

3rd November 2015 - Research project finds Whitsunday Islands littered with rubbish

10th April 2017 - Sunshine Coast helps out Whitsundays with post Cyclone Debbie conference relocation

1st February 2011 - Cyclone Yasi Forces Whitsunday Resort Evacuations

28th November 2013 - Ocean rips kill more than bushfires, cyclones, floods or shark attacks

11th May 2017 - Whitehaven Beach reopens after restoration and clean-up

Asking a small favour
We hope that you value the news that we publish so while you're here can we ask for your support?

The news we publish at is independent, credible (we hope) and free for you to access, with no pay walls and no annoying pop-up ads.

However, as an independent publisher, can we ask for you to support us by subscribing to the printed Australasian Leisure Management magazine - if you don't already do so.

Published bi-monthly since 1997, the printed Australasian Leisure Management differs from this website in that it publishes longer, in-depth and analytical features covering aquatics, attractions, entertainment, events, fitness, parks, recreation, sport, tourism and venues management.

Subscriptions cost just $90 a year.

Click here to subscribe.


supplier directory

The Complete Guide to Leisure Industry Products & Services.

See the directory see all

SeatGeek Asia Pacific

SeatGeek is a search engine and mobile-focused ticket marketplace that allows fans to buy and sell tickets for live events. As of August 2018, SeatGeek has exited the Australian, New…

read more

Entertainment / Sport / Technology / Ticketing / Venues



About Priava's Technology -  Priava is a cloud-based and centralised venue and event management system aimed at venues of all sizes. With its familiar and easy-to-use web interface, the…

read more

Attractions / Billing / Entertainment / Events / Technology


Tim Batt Water Solutions

Tim Batt Water Solutions are at the very forefront of the commercial aquatic business in Australia, with over 30 years specific experience supplying and installing chemical control and dosing…

read more

Aquatics / Environment / Recreation / Technology / Venues



Commercial Aquatics Australia provides aquatic solutions nationwide and is one of the largest and most experienced companies specialising in the design, construction, renovation, service, maintenance…

read more

Aquatics / Design / Play / Waterparks


Aflex Inflatables

Aflex Inflatables are the leaders for obstacle courses, pool toys, waterparks and land-based watersides and fitness runs. They are industry leaders offering the widest range of pool, lake and beach…

read more

Aquatics / Play / Waterparks



Ausfit began in 1992, providing software services to the health and fitness sector including ClubWise, a fully hosted web-based product which combines state of the art club management software,…

read more

Billing / Finance / Fitness / Technology


Otium Planning Group

Otium Planning Group is a contemporary sport and leisure consultancy providing services in planning, facility development, management and funding for the sport, recreation and leisure industries…

read more

Aquatics / Consultants / Recreation / Sport / Venues


Jonas Leisure

JonasLeisure offers a complete range of leading leisure and recreation software brands – envibe, Centaman, Gladstone Health & Leisure, The Retention People, Nutrition Complete and…

read more

Aquatics / Billing / Fitness / Recreation / Sport


get listed with our suppliers directory

Get your business noticed in our targeted directory. Viewed by 10,000 industry professionals per week!

list your business