Hadley Australia and Series Australia Pty Ltd are the leading quality theatre chair manufacturers in the southern hemisphere. The businesses work closely with architects, interior designers and…read more
AFC President’s FIFA presidential bid mired in human rights abuse allegations
Assertions by Asian Football Confederation (AFC) President Sheikh Salman Bin Ebrahim Al Khalifa, a candidate for the presidency of world football body FIFA, that he was not involved in the arrest and abuse of sports executives and athletes in his natïve Bahrain in 2011 raise more questions than answers according to regular contributor James M. Dorsey.
Sheikh Salman’s rise in world football governance since he became AFC President in 2013 have been dogged by allegations that he headed a Bahraini Government committee established to identify sports executives and athletes who had participated in the 2011 popular revolt.
Some 200 people were arrested, including three top players of the Bahraini national football team, two of which alongside scores of others allege that they were tortured while in detention.
Sheikh Salman, who at the time headed the Bahrain Football Association (BFA), has until the announcement last month of his FIFA presidential candidacy, refused to discuss the allegations beyond issuing flat denials.
FIFA is scheduled to elect a new president on 26th February.
However, Sheikh Salman has since provided greater detail in statements and interviews in which he described the claims as “false, nasty lies.”
However, rather than absolving him, Sheikh Salman’s statements raised the spectre of potential violations of FIFA’s ethics code.
Former FIFA ethics investigator Michael Garcia advised the Bahrain Institute for Rights and Democracy (BIRD) in early 2014 before leaving the world football body that the allegations against Sheikh Salman were beyond his jurisdiction. That view could be revised in the murky politics of the scandal-ridden group.
BIRD’s London representative, Sayed Ahmed Alwadaei, was arrested in 2011 and abused after participating in an anti-government protest involving sports executives and athletes. Alwadaei, who served six months in prison alongside several athletes for participating in an illegal gathering and allegedly disseminating false information to the media, said he was “sexually harassed, beaten, insulted and humiliated.”
His assertions echoed those of prominent national football team players Alaa and Mohammed Hubail.
Sheikh Salman effectively confirmed the existence of a 2011 decree by a fellow member of the Gulf island’s ruling family, Prince Nasser bin Hamad al-Khalifa, ordering the establishment of a committee to identify dissident sports executives and athletes. Prince Nasser, a son of Bahraini King Hamad bin Isa Al Khalifa, chairs the Supreme Council for Youth and Sports as well as the Bahrain National Olympic Committee and commands Bahrain’s Royal Guard.
Sheikh Salman said in a statement “while it was proposed that Sheikh Salman lead a fact-finding committee in relation to the events of 2011, that committee was never formally established and never conducted any business whatsoever.
“For the record, and in light of the recycling of historic allegations in the media, Sheikh Salman had absolutely no involvement in the identification, investigation, prosecution or mistreatment of any individuals as has been alleged.”
Sheikh Salman’s statement studiously avoided credible reports that he had been appointed and apparently accepted to be head of the committee irrespective of whether it was ultimately established or not.
The Bahrain News Agency (BNA), a state-run media organisation that falls under the information ministry and only runs government-sanctioned items, reported on 11th April 2011 that the committee was being formed and that it was headed by Sheikh Salman.
One 11th April 2011 it reported “Sheikh Salman bin Ebrahim al-Khalifa, General Secretary of Youth and Sport, will lead the investigation committee.”
There is no record of Sheikh Salman denying the report at the time.
Sheikh Salman moreover took no exception to the notion of a committee that would penalise executives and athletes for exercising their right to freedom of expression nor did he express any objection to detention and physical and psychological abuse of those often lifted in the middle of the night from their beds.
Asked in 2012 about the crackdown on dissident athletes and executives, Sheikh Salman asserted that he had no obligation to defend football players who “did something wrong” off the field.
Nor did Sheikh Salman take any exception to national football team players being put in a talk show on state-run Bahrain television shortly before their arrest in front of what amounted to a kangaroo court during which Prince Nasser in a live on-air phone call called for “a wall to fall on (protesters’) heads … even if they are an athlete.”
Prince Nasser subsequently tweeted that “If it was up to me, I’d give them all life” in prison.
Sheikh Salman’s denial is further called into question by statements by his secretary general of the BFA as well as by heads of other Bahraini sports associations who declared their intent to act on Prince Nasser’s instructions in stories carried by BNA.
There is no record of Sheikh Salman denying a statement by BFA secretary general Abdulrahman Al Sayar reported by BNA that his association would sanction and suspend athletes who had violated the law whether they were "players or administrators or coaches" and irrespective of whether they had participated in protests or illegal gatherings that constituted an “attempt to overthrow the regime or insult national symbols.”
Al Sayer said the BFA was acting in accordance with Prince Nasser’s order and in defense of security and the achievements of the Al Khalifa’s “prosperous reign.”
Al Sayer’s statement and Sheikh Salman’s silence make a mockery of the AFC president’s denial of his involvement, which he based in part on an assertion that the BFA had nothing to do with politics.
Similarly, BNA reported that Bahrain Basketball Association President Adel Al Assomi had formed a committee to probe "irresponsible" violations by players and administrative and technical staff who had participated in protests calling for the downfall of the minority Sunni regime and offended “the kingdom’s wise leadership and fundamentals.”
The agency reported a little more than a week after it had announced Sheikh Salman’s appointment that six Shiite football clubs had been suspended and fined $20,000 each.
It said further that Al Ahli Sports Club banned seven football players from playing and suspended three others for allegedly participating in the mass protests that were brutally squashed with the backing of Saudi and Gulf troops. The penalizing of the clubs came after they had asked the BFA to suspend the football league because of the upheaval wracking the country.
The decision to penalise the clubs, according to BNA, was taken in a meeting of the executive committee of the BFA chaired by Sheikh Salman that reaffirmed the importance of “working under the investigation committee” with regard to those who “offended the decisions of our leadership.”
All in all, Sheikh Salman’s denials have done little to satisfactorily answer persistent questions about his role in the repression of dissident athletes and sports executives in 2011. His suitability for the FIFA presidency remains in doubt as long as he fails to provide fulsome answers.
Moreover, those unanswered questions come in addition to Sheikh Salman’s track record at the AFC of secrecy and lack of transparency and accountability, hardly characteristics that would enable a new president to restore FIFA’s bruised credibility.
James M. Dorsey is a senior fellow at the S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies, co-director of the University of Würzburg’s Institute for Fan Culture, and the author of The Turbulent World of Middle East Soccer blog and a forthcoming book with the same title.
Images: Sheikh Salman with currently suspended FIFA President Sepp Blatter (top) and Sheikh Salman in his role as AFC President.
19th June 2015 - SOOSAY RESIGNS FROM ASIAN FOOTBALL CONFEDERATION
18th April 2014 - SCANDAL-RIDDEN ASIAN FOOTBALL BODY STYMIES REFORM EFFORTS
17th April 2013 - ECCLESTONE BACKS BAHRAIN GRAND PRIX DESPITE THREAT OF VIOLENCE
Asking a small favour
We hope that you value the news that we publish so while you're here can we ask for your support?
The news we publish at www.ausleisure.com.au is independent, credible (we hope) and free for you to access, with no pay walls and no annoying pop-up ads.
However, as an independent publisher, can we ask for you to support us by subscribing to the printed Australasian Leisure Management magazine - if you don't already do so.
Published bi-monthly since 1997, the printed Australasian Leisure Management differs from this website in that it publishes longer, in-depth and analytical features covering aquatics, attractions, entertainment, events, fitness, parks, recreation, sport, tourism and venues management.
Subscriptions cost just $90 a year.
Click here to subscribe.
The Complete Guide to Leisure Industry Products & Services.
Hidroplay welcomes you to the exciting world of children's Playscapes, waterslide's and Water Attractions. Appealing to families, Hidroplay increases patronage in your facility during those…read more
Vlocker Pty Ltd has been designing, manufacturing, installing and servicing locker systems worldwide since 1995. Vlocker specialises in providing locker solutions to suit client requirements in…read more
Commercial Aquatics Australia provides aquatic solutions nationwide and is one of the largest and most experienced companies specialising in the design, construction, renovation, service, maintenance…read more
Technogym is the leading company in the Wellness and Fitness field all over the world. With 2,200 employees, 14 branches in Europe, U.S., South America, Asia and Australia, Technogym exports its…read more
Rhinoplay offers playground equipment in Australia that is safe, durable, and most importantly fun! We specialise in creating unique indoor playgrounds for play centres and outdoor playgrounds for…read more
Links Modular Solutions are a leading provider of high-quality, innovative software solutions for leisure facilities. Our software suite includes modules such as POS, Classes, Members, Facility…read more
Anti Wave International is the original suppliers of top performance swim, aquatic sports, leisure and pool programming equipment. Founded in 1971, Anti Wave International is proud of its…read more
get listed with our suppliers directory
Get your business noticed in our targeted directory. Viewed by 10,000 industry professionals per week!